HPB Minutes 2010-0622 - Laserfiche WebLink

Home Browse Search

building and the fact that it is the site of an historic event, the Holocaust Survivors ceremony that was held in 2004, they believe that fills the criteria in the Code,and her recommendation is that Temple B'Nai Zion, which includes the Main Sanctuary, the Portico, and the Memorial Tower, does in fact qualify under Section 171-5(B)and 171-5(C)of the City Code,and that it is eligible for historic site designation. Public Speakers: Keith Poliakoff, Esq.; Joseph B. Kaller, Architect; Marla Sherman Dumas; Rabbi Aaron Lankry; Harvey Busch; Rabbi Moshe Matz; Paul Feldman; [City Clerk's Note: Keith Poliakoff, Esq. handed out the Power Point Presentation Material, a Speech by Rabbi Aaron Lankry, and a Speech by Robert Solera) Keith Poliakoff, Esq. of Becker& Poliakoff,P.A.,reported and gave a power point presentation on the background of Temple'Thai Zion. He also went over the presentation outline introducing Architect and Historic Preservationist Joseph B. Kaller, and former Sunny Isles Beach Community Planning and Development Director Marla Sherman Dumas. He also noted that he and City Attorney Ottinot had a disagreement on whether former Sunny Isles Beach employee Robert Solera could speak tonight, he is speaking from his personal perspective and not being hired or paid by any of them and therefore not a Lobbyist, and he also noted that Rabbi Aaron Lankry, the President of the Temple, is here tonight and will speak. Joseph B. Kaller,of Joseph B. Kaller& Associates, P.A.,continued the power point presentation on the history of Sunny Isles Beach, including a review of the existing architecture along the beach of Sunny Isles Beach from the north end of the City to the south end. He also gave additional background on the Temple, including the existing floor plan showing that the altar is facing west instead of east toward Jerusalem. The Temple hired Architect Kobi Karp to come up with a solution of what can be built on that site. He showed the proposed rendering which has been designed consistently with Jewish traditions and facing east, with the form of the building reminiscent of the Star of David. Former City employee Marla Sherman Dumas continued the power point presentation on the site and building, and she went through the City's Historic Preservation Board's efforts throughout the years. Ms. Dumas testified as to the City's Code criteria noting that there are six standards for designation contained in the City's Historic Landmark Ordinance, and responded to the City's Historic Designation Report. She urged the Board to deny the designation of the Temple as an historic site/building. Former City employee Robert Solera came to the podium but City Attorney Ottinot said for the record that Mr. Solera is not qualified to appear before this Board under the City's Ethics Code and the County's Ethics Code based on the fact that Mr. Solera is a former employee and has not served his two years service from the date of his resignation from the City. If he testifies before this Board he will be subject to an Ethics Code complaint with the Miami-Dade County Commission on Ethics. Mr. Poliakoff disagreed with City Attorney Ottinot and said Mr. Solera is not lobbying or being paid by his firm, and he called Rabbi Lankry to testify next in order for him to look into this. Rabbi Aaron Lankry, President of Temple B'Nai Zion, gave some background information and how he came to this Temple and its history with the City. He said the Temple has no interest in being declared historic, and he asked the Board to reject this application. Summary Minutes: 2010-0622 HPB Mtg Page 2 of 8