Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutReso 2024-3624RESOLUTION NO. 2024 - S A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF SUNNY ISLES BEACH, FLORIDA, APPROVING THE SELECTION OF UNITED HEALTHCARE AS THE PROVIDER OF EMPLOYEE HEALTH INSURANCE; UNITED HEALTHCARE DENTAL AS THE PROVIDER OF DENTAL INSURANCE; EYEMED AS THE PROVIDER OF VISION CARE; MUTUAL OF OMAHA AS THE PROVIDER OF LIFE INSURANCE, ACCIDENTAL, DEATH & DISMEMBERMENT (AD&D) INSURANCE, LONG TERM DISABILITY INSURANCE, VOLUNTARY SHORT TERM DISABILITY INSURANCE, AND VOLUNTARY LIFE INSURANCE, FOR A ONE-YEAR PERIOD; AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO ENTER INTO AGREEMENTS WITH THESE PROVIDERS, PROVIDED SAID AGREEMENTS ARE APPROVED AS TO FORM AND LEGAL SUFFICIENCY BY THE CITY ATTORNEY; FURTHER AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO DO ALL THINGS NECESSARY TO EFFECTUATE THIS RESOLUTION; PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. WHEREAS, the City of Sunny Isles Beach (the "City") currently provides regular full-time and part-time employees with primary health care through Cigna Healthcare, a full-service healthcare provider; and WHEREAS, staff requested the City's insurance broker, Brown & Brown Insurance, Inc. ("B&B"), to issue proposals on behalf of the City to provide insurance coverages at generally the same levels as the existing coverage; and WHEREAS, after extensive negotiations with the various providers, B&B and staff recommend acceptance of the proposal submitted by United Healthcare in an annual amount of $3,383,068.00, with employees having the option to choose from two (2) plans: UHC Buy Up Plan or UHC Base Plan; and WHEREAS, Untied Healthcare has submitted a proposal for Dental Services at an annual amount of $168,834.00, with employees having the option to choose from two (2) plans: DMO or PPO; and WHEREAS, EyeMed has extended their current rates at no additional cost, in an annual amount of $21,027.00; and WHEREAS, Mutual of Omaha has extended their current rates at no additional cost, in the amount of $84,000.00 as the City's provider for life, long-term disability and accidental death and dismemberment (AD&D) insurance, and at the employee's sole cost, the voluntary short term disability insurance and voluntary life insurance, in an annual amount of $60,000.00; and WHEREAS, these agreements are for a period of one (1) year, with coverage beginning March 1, 2024, for a total amount not to exceed Three Million Nine Hundred Sixteen Thousand Nine Hundred Twenty -Nine Dollars and No Cents ($3,916,929.00), which includes a contingency in the amount of Two Hundred Thousand Dollars and No Cents ($200,000.00) , for any unforeseen increases. @BCL@4COB168C.Doc Page 1 of 2 247 NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF SUNNY ISLES BEACH, FLORIDA, AS FOLLOWS: Section 1. Approval of City Commission. The City Commission hereby approves the use of United Healthcare as the City's health care provider, United Healthcare Dental as the dental insurance provider, EyeMed as the vision care provider, and Mutual of Omaha as the City's provider for life, accidental death and dismemberment (AD&D) insurance, long-term disability insurance, voluntary short-term disability insurance, and voluntary life insurance, for a one-year period, with coverage beginning March 1, 2024, for a total amount not to exceed Three Million Nine Hundred Sixteen Thousand Nine Hundred Twenty -Nine Dollars and No Cents ($3,916,929.00), which includes a contingency in the amount of Two Hundred Thousand Dollars and No Cents ($200,000.00) for any unforeseen increases. Section 2. Authorization of City Manager. The City Manager is hereby authorized to enter into agreements with said insurance providers, provided said agreements are approved as to form and legal sufficiency by the City Attorney. Section 3. Further Authorization of the City Manager. The City Manager is hereby authorized to do all other things necessary to effectuate this Resolution. Section 4. Effective Date. This Resolution shall become effective upon adoption. PASSED AND ADOPTED on this 15th d of Fe uary, 2024. ATTEST: X Mau?icid Betandur, CMC, City Clerk Larisa Svechin, Mayor APPROVED AS TO FORM AND LEGAL SUFFICIENCY: A I - 01P. -,;,, e. f, Iain E. Boileau, for Nabors, Giblin & Nickerson, P.A., City Attorney Moved by: 1 �f✓ /7r!;�% 4d41:11!11 _Seconded by: Vote: Mayor Svechin—"Yes) (No) Vice Mayor Lama (Yes) (No) Commissioner Joseph 17� (Yes) (No) Commissioner Stuyvesant (Yes) 3 (No) Commissioner Viscarra (Yes) (No) @BCL@4COB168C.Doc Page 2 of 2 248 Insurance Summary 2024 Provider Insurance Type Summary The recommendation is to switch to United Healthcare for medical insurance. This was the most competitive proposal received. Due to the high claims experience this past year; Cigna proposed a rate increase of approximately 35% (annual amount of $4,159,863.00). Cigna Medical After extensive negotiations with various carriers, we elected Healthcare to switch to United Healthcare, who submitted a proposal with a rate increase of approximately 9.4% for the UHC Buy Up Plan and 11.1% for the UHC Base Plan (approximate annual amount* of $3,383,068.00), with no plan changes. (Savings of approximately $776,795 — renewal vs. new plan) The recommendation is to switch to United Healthcare for dental insurance. This was the most competitive proposal received. Cigna provided a proposal with a rate increase of approximately 7.5% for the Cigna PPO Dental Plan and 3% for the Cigna DMO Plan (approximate annual amount of Cigna Dental $192,984), with no plan changes. Dental After extensive negotiations with various carriers, we elected to switch to United Healthcare, who submitted a proposal with a rate decrease of approximately 5.9% for the UHC PPO Dental Plan and 10.3% for the Cigna DMO Plan (approximate annual amount* of $168,834), with no plan changes. (Savings of approximately $24,750.00 — renewal vs. new plan) Eyemed has extended their current rates at no additional cost. EyeMed Vision Approximate annual amount* of $21,027. This will be the third year of a four-year rate guarantee. Life; Accidental Mutual of Omaha has extended their current rates at no Death & additional cost. Approximate annual amount* of $84,000.00 Mutual of Dismemberment; Omaha Long -Term Disability; Mutual of Omaha has extended their current rates at no Voluntary Short additional cost. Approximate annual amount* of $60,000.00 Mutual of Term Disability and Omaha Voluntary Life Voluntary Short -Term Disability and Voluntary Life Insurance Insurance is at the sole cost of the employee. *Please note that annual amount presented is an approximation based on current enrollment of active employees, COBRA participants and retirees. Amounts may vary or fluctuate throughout the plan year based on new enrollments, addition of dependents or IRS allowed plan changes. 249 0 0 N 0 o 0 N O c m t Ee <n n N M m N a LL O O N N N a G U C �- 0 O '^ EL o 0 o 0❑ m m m 0 N 9 0 0 - - 0 0 Z O o Z Q Z z m ua O -. of m a w h_ j O N d N h N Q Q¢¢ b 43 VI O J Z Q C v M m' ¢ in o n 6 n v uni cl N N z C ~ N N � o a m a a a a a 2 N a Z C m O :•,: z L V L ug' O O m m Q O Q¢ m m Q Q 2 In In ❑ Z o p, Q 2 o z m c Q Z N vNi .n QQ 2z Z z N !c O o m> o 0 0 0 o a a ¢ n m m M. z z z nm m o m N rn VI a IA a '. lV G .o N o o p❑ a a a D O O Z m uoi v O m w N U VOI N¢¢¢¢ N Z N ZCL o a m n o o z O < u> m -q w N a ¢ N o m m n m m O m ryp+ C z Q O e0 INn Z Z m D Q m D Q❑ a D Q Q z ❑ D. ❑ z C fL '.. ;f a o a a o o o N 'm Q¢¢ z r r z Q¢ o In o m z o N r^ 2 m c Q Z. ur w N¢? rmi Z Z Z a Qa 5. - C z C z ri m v 0 ii 4is N00 O O O ? pp m E N 41 M (y N C u n m^ mo _ Q ¢ N m Q Q m m ❑ ❑ N o p D w m' m N m Q¢¢ Q Z n m N N C d 0 0 0 0 (00 O N O N m OI O N O Q li oN r n a Nrj m CI N w Dm p o Z U rn ` m o o m N N N us f O M N W ¢¢¢¢ i0ll Z N N _ Z Z U m l00 o b m> ¢ z ¢ z m U 0 m N ci M N Vr 3 m O >; c m 3 K m ❑ m m �' n m L` `�' � m' A � N a m aami m m ami mS Z' c c u j a' E m `m a m o o t _ l7 a v c c i. a` U S a>> E w=_ m r 0 a 9 L 0 a c m 0 ro ir X m m U c m 0~ d a N p c D ... m e E E w w E E w w c w .3 > > .+ h j Im- I u 0_ a C a d O o ci O i �m :c <° 0 0 N r-� Irl Ln N d E 'o 0 0 .00 u mo v o 0 0 0 c�nrn W O � Nim N apo N 0 N n Y L CO O In U m . +r m fl M • � N � o � �. 1 O fA O O c O O o o p p V O d a O o 0 O O 0 a O O 0� e o O Q O 0 O o o Of m cO � G M Z CV! In fA O U o Q: M O. �p • �: E 0 eaa�u�ao v m v w r Q Q Q U O y L L L p N m N CO O iG U T •. M Z -p Z z z 2ZZZ z U) } UUU ffl yl O_� y9 Z �, M M O z O O z z �v _ - • �� � pm vvm 65 m Z O a o �mupi 0 o C V N " o �oppomupimupi�wm a` o •o \ 0 0 0 C �fI m rN.-V N N m i't uoi uoia} 0 • a N N C N �. U N 3 0 0 0 0 o a o w p N r C N O O Zo N j� Z co - 0 0 0 0 ba 0 ow a U i O 0 V Obi 'mow V! .� fff ffl In _ C O p m cp m � �, N v. E 0 N m ems. O rnrnrn C m > > • Z ZZ z IjZ } UUU�,n aen vs Z w • e' O O O O N v z z z a x N O 6 ci M M N m; m m U L y C O m c y C ai 6, •� .aa o `. c E > m >o- o w m v a N^ o` ao' N E is K c „alp u • _ o a8 c r o B' B D} a m > c m m o 0 ' a 0 n o o v `-' m o' v u° gg ° r o m m H c 3ov G LL 'S d _ e E a a O d c> E c m o m m o E� l j u�. .`3 N c c c m �u L a .10. pm�, ami umi ami ami E m E °t p, E p R c u o m 9 aci u ovo of w c m vii 0; c° f7 V o 0 o O c p p {� > >> c E `° m m m m'oam�0 e. m '° m x m m m;u t w o E o 2 o `m 3: .'� mO o ;; E E E E A owwwww c Ei,g tm- o, �. w ix Irl Ln N > cn t 0 Lc u c,' 0 (D > 4 p CD �o 'o a a CD U� 0 0 0 0 C3 to Lo U� Ea 69 11 E E E F- y pr - 40 N CO 41). tni LO a �2 �2 c� M ca c) + Go N'q -IT C� f m to CMO 6.1 ca CL M Co to Ln M > W 04 M C4 RIO c 69 .C3 0 (D b 0� to 0 0 c) p U') 0 0 0 o 0 bF co C� C� ;z 69 U') -4t w CO v LO (0 611 1'- 6.� CJ 11 E E E 6< ON 77 to (D > ca 0 Gi ci ug, tell E2 c LU N co U, N cl It " '2 c o N N (n C', 6v C13 0 O LO C 10 C) Lo CO 'o C, C:) LO 0 o st c) C') o to C) I- C:l 0 r_ 0 C 0 C', C.) ba Ull U� 69 Y) E E E iri co cli r- CN N U CL + 0 L� 10 0 -U) 0 0, 0) 09. 0 (D C: cn 0 a) -i CY m LL t) 0 U) 0 'Z3 I c 0 12 E 'E: u) E F- (D Co 0 -6 C: c: Q C Q) a) c) c a -J X - T- ;w m r E o E 0 cl m 2 a) ul — a) In W w U) 0 cu ck) 0 w 0 .2 -2 0 0 a' t 2 = 0 1 U) LL 0 I - u c -1 L) (o 0 > U C: E Q u q) 19 a o E 0 0 2 0 0 ra 0 = c m + + + 2 (D (D GE ..o cc (D 0 V A, :5 a, -J S)- E 0 > 0 Cc % > -2 wx (D a U) U, S. zo . '. *9 . 0 2 0 E c' 2 E :3 ro- 0 E E E 5 0 .- E E WE E w w w w 0 611, 69 Q- 0 LL 0 -si 0 U� x -i U. o F - Lu fL 0: I -* IM n 0 a) U) U Of m Q x M N (U o 0 0 0 o 0 y f a 0 m CO) E CD o W Eq W 0 T 0 0 o LL to ft: O O q,i N Y O 0 O O C. -M 0 OLo �. a -y0 U 0 O N Z` ,. o O O. M O t N lV •+ y a G) O 6qo O O y j N 0 7 C 7 fNA p12 o 00 C 0 O O N O O O O N O O - e- N V)� M yr�y' C Oi 6) j/j m U) m (f)oo Z o t» to N N T N O 0 O 0 C:) O O O O O TC. c tq 64 m ,4. LL O 1 4%= v T Y O O E >co fA C� EA t u y Z Z m @ c0 to � X O O 00 O O 0 �. N .. r cm O O O m O y U 'o a O Om NO` 0 O O MMU O NNC 0 0 Oo b p CN (D tOo O mU 0 mvN.U co00 O o — Vi efl ai rn y LL .>_ — o m m Z a . ¢ Q N w m W NN m O O O U ` O O O Q O O c O U T?� 0 0 Q Q y y y cr Cy, i m y � >i 0 0 E o 00 � c o o y `m E 0 = 0 M cc o 0 o a °'yEEE, a E E 0 E c C o E¢" f - y E y m= d 0 ND 'o O. > w mC, o> o a n. 9 Q y a m 0 E ;> .v y �> c wp N y`o w. m a.m p : 6 011 .J E 7 Z E A N u) a � r C C 22 a� w. m m Lrj N 0 O E 6 C N; >° Oti^• i { • ma L.. N 002 k t N RJ t '.. • m •. O N E z i p $ Nmmm cn oOO�g7N ¢ oO m _O O 'C0a N~_ 1A O 01 O .�>, ffl O c? z Q a 504 O L 'ga':; f CL u� N l 7 fA ti 7i ¢ ? 3 rY P � }VV oO ` 5 k, A{$ m m ` C ppei N 0 8# Ocx S E -?5 O N I 0? p O N N N E ''f 31W o a � N C C V 'm0 'm0 jjt t O ti' 0 ¢¢ • N.T o O CO00 O O EP O N r 00 00 N O �r2 O O U 3 0 7 U l' �5 0 OIO p N' NIO L co Q, O? },M sLti; r N N N N C _ C C X4111 Of C> mO1 EA i i z¢¢ aL`` w t ¢ O 0 m m N @ "g, x m 4t �. X U 0 1 gi ` N = N m N IV w0 • O N ,$ ," C (r L A C O L{ 3 N E L CC iYm>. OLO p ' o N = j ? Ia0 N O N>0¢ ' mT. m O° ggf_ O O r m st V U C U C UO Cj ER Lq C 7 f..11`4 Q d L tm of ID ca (n CCX F - LL E q m 10 ro v o m m E o •y E(u c m o� ?� ; e m P. t{J�'. cr E •> E E o ° m O C .0 C O C C O q. C O .Ga+ y .00 •r�+ cr m m J y O Y O E 4 p t V G O m 0 C IjO. y QIL m¢ G i t .0 N ° m a E j e 3 U pm' u. c r. m V o_ r m a C c C v m a O o C � O „, - m p c E b 0 rn d y m a°° m :9 no d m 0 E 3 m m iC m '� C 'E C G i '�• X w O O a a (9 aci N t >> .'o N ami O m . E E t n w m a m aci e 0 mid ® E E m « m E a U) < w U) w m m x > bpi m wm wI Q.wwQ.w� 0 w QU E 7 Z E A N u) a � r C C 22 a� w. m m Lrj N E C E V% CO CL Y Y L > m a) ca w C _ a) w d a) O N m 69, yai LO x U N a) U f)Y)m a T a3 Y Y a) a) m Q a R D N N > N _ 0 U o � N v �= N N J E O" T v � W T O = d 7 E CI `y C (0 m O m a u N O L = C J L .O 3 � E > J V � C d � c > 3 m 3 rn v � `> m o c u 0 0 N � N V d C O 0 E o N Y v O 3 d m _ T N > d to L O c N N N N 'C O U 0 N E v t w r m d N E v � c d j J u W c x� o m N c0 v o <D } y Q O _ Ts LO N IT O ti 30 N :J m 0 LL J O m A 0 CO Voluntary Life Insurance PROPOSED CURRENT .. maha Humana Mutual S Class Description Al1l1 Eligible Employees g All Eligible Employees All Eligible Employees ployee ees Excep t Elected I Officials Employee Minimum Benefit Amount $10,000 $10,000 510,000 Maximum Benefit Amount Up to $500,000 not to exceed 7x employee's salary Up to $500,000 not to exceed 7x Up to $500,000 not to exceed 7x employee's salary employee's salary Increments $10,000 $10,000 $10.000 Guarantee Issue (GI) $150,000 $150,000 $150,000 Reduction of Benefits Reduces to Reduces to Reduces by at a e 65 65% 65% 35% at age 70 40% 40% 60% at age 75 25% 25% 75% Spouse ! Maximum Benefit Amount Up to 5250,000 not to exceed 100% of employee's amount. Coverage terminates at age 70 Up to $250,000 not to exceed 100% of Up to $250,000 not to exceed 50 % of employee's amount. Coverage employee's amount terminates at age 70 Minimum Benefit Amount $5,000 $5,000 $5,000 Increments $5,000 $5,000 $5,000 Guarantee Issue (GI) $50,000 $50,000 $50,000 Child(ren) E t Minimum Benefit Amount $500 Maximum Benefit Amount $10,000 not to exceed 100% of emplo ee's amount $10.000 not to exceed 100% of employee's amount Up to $10,000 Guarantee Issue (GI) $10,000 $10,000 $10,000 Benefit Schedule 14 Days to age 26 $10,000 14 Days to age 26 0. 14 days $0 15 days - 6 mo $500 $10,000 6 months -age 19 810,000 (26 if FT student) tivelyatWork Included Included Included giver of Premium _ Included Included Included Portability_ Included Included Conversion Included Included Accelerated Death Benefit Included Included Included Minimum Participation Requirement 35% 35% 25% Rate Guarantee Expires 2/29/2024 12 Months 24'Months, Wit mated Rates; life` Iftte); 1,000 Life R Wif,$1,000 Life` 660/111, Age Employee Spouse Employee Spouse Employee, Spouse Q4 $0.080 $0.080 $0.080 $0.080 $0.080 $0.080 25-29 $0.080 $0.080 $0.080 $0.080 $0.080 ` $0.080 30-34 $0.090 $0.090 $0.090 $0.090 $0.090r $0.090 35-39 $0.150 $0.150 $0.150 $0.150 $0.150 $0.150 40.44 $0.270 $0.270 50.270 $0.270 $0.270 $0.270 4549 $0.470 $0.470 $0.470 $0.470 $0.470 SOA70 50-54 $0.730 $0.730 $0.730 $0.730 $0.730 S0.730 55-59 $1.100 $1.100 $1.100 $1.100 $1.100 51.100 60-64 $1.840 $1.840 $1.840 $1.840 $1.840 S1.840 65-69 $3.360 $3.360 $3.360 $3.360 $3.360 53.380 70-74 $4.760 n/a $4.760 n/a $4.760 54.760 75+ $10.340 n/a $10.340 Na $10.340 $10.340 Spouse's rate based upon Employee's age. Employee's age AD&D Yale per $1,000 of coverage Employee $0.030 $0.030Ls0.030 Spouse $0.030 $0.0300.030 Children $0,030 $0.030 Child(ren)life rate per S1,000 of coves a $0.200 $0.2000.200 It the d-bollycemer Is not the Same as the life canner, the employer neeas to file the waiver o1 prommin win Ilse This quote doesn't Include OE and late lire carrier d an ompinyoe quiches for r9satnhtyenrollees will be required to provide EOI Active at work requirement: Employees not 'actively at work' on the tat day of coverage will rentmn covered under the prior carrier until they meet Ihe'active at work requirement' under the new r-arner ati .,, _ ,, 256 Nk-.2 City of Sunny Isles Beach 18070 Collins Avenue Sunny Isles Beach, Florida 33160 p9)kQby of S,Q, 'Rav (305) 947-0606 City Hall (305) 949-3113 Fax MEMORANDUM TO: Honorable Mayor and City Commissioners VIA: Stan Morris, City Manager FROM: Yael Y. LondoA±o, Human Resources and Risk Management Director DATE: February 15, 2024 RE: Approval of Selection of 2024 Insurance Providers RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends approval of this Resolution. REASONS: The City makes available various insurances as a benefit to its employees. The insurances promote health, wellness, and protection. As such, staff requested the City's insurance brokers (Brown and Brown) issue requests for proposals for insurance coverage at basically the same levels as the existing coverage. After extensive negotiations with the various providers, Brown & Brown and staff recommend acceptance of the following provider proposals. See Attachment A (Insurance Summary Table and Proposals). ' ADDITIONAL INFORMATION: Staff worked diligently with our brokers to secure the best pricing and plans for our insurance coverage. Proposals that seemed competitive, but did not meet our plan standards were eliminated from consideration. Employees will be advised of the changes and we have tentatively scheduled information and enrollment sessions, in order to effectuate any changes by March 1, 2024, provided receipt of City Commission approval. Lastly, all of the recommended providers have an AM Best's Rating of "A" which is "Superior" to "Ver) Good and all agreements will be reviewed as to form and legal sufficiency by the Office of the City Attorney. A complete set of all of the final proposals will be on file in the City Clerk's Office. Please note that annual amounts presented in this resolution are an approximation based on current Item Number: 10.1 245 enrollment of active employees, COBRA participants and retirees. Amounts may vary or fluctuat( throughout plan year based on new enrollments, addition of dependents or IRS allowed plan changes. Therefore this resolution also includes a contingency in the amount of $200,000 to cover the aforementioned potential increases or expenses. FUNDING SOURCE: Funding is available in the 42300 (Benefits - Health and Dental) & 423001 (Benefits - Life, ADD & LTC Personnel Services Accounts in each department and/or division. ATTACHMENTS: Resolution Insurance Summary 2024.pdf Final Rate Sheet 2024.pdf Item Number: 10.1 246