HomeMy WebLinkAboutHPB Reso 2011-14HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD RESOLUTION NO. 2011 - 1 �
A RESOLUTION OF THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION
BOARD OF THE CITY OF SUNNY ISLES BEACH, FLORIDA,
APPROVING THE APPLICATION FOR CERTIFICATION OF
APPROPRIATENESS TO DEMOLISH AND RECONSTRUCT
THE SUNNY ISLES BEACH PIER, ATTACHED HERETO AS
EXHIBIT "A "; PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS, a primary function of the Historic Preservation Board of the City of Sunny
Isles Beach (the "Board ") is to designate, preserve, protect and maintain historic buildings in the
City of Sunny Isles Beach (the "City "); and
WHEREAS, the property known as the Sunny Isles Beach Pier (a/k/a Newport Fishing
Pier), located at 16701 Collins Avenue, was originally built in 1936 and quickly became a
popular destination for fishing enthusiasts and sightseers from around the world; and
WHEREAS, the Sunny Isles Beach Pier was designated by the Miami -Dade County
Historic Preservation Board as a historic site on January 21, 1982, and later re- designated as a
historic site by the City of Sunny Isles Beach Historic Preservation Board on June 6, 2005; and
WHEREAS, the Sunny Isles Beach Pier sustained major structural damage during
Hurricane Wilma in 2005, and has since been closed to the public due to unsafe conditions; and
WHEREAS, the City desires to demolish and reconstruct the existing Sunny Isles Beach
Pier structure and restaurant and replace it with a new pier and restaurant within the same
footprint, as set forth in the Application for Certification of Appropriateness attached hereto as
Exhibit "A "; and
WHEREAS, the City of Sunny Isles Beach Historic Preservation Board is required to
render decisions on applications for certificates of appropriateness seeking the demolition or
reconstruction of a designated historic landmark within the City.
NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION
BOARD OF THE CITY OF SUNNY ISLES BEACH, FLORIDA, AS FOLLOWS:
Section 1. Incorporation of Recitals. The foregoing recital paragraphs are hereby ratified
and confirmed as being true and the same are hereby made part of this Resolution.
Section 2. Approval of Application for Certification of Appropriateness. The City's Historic
Preservation Board finds that the Application for Certification of Appropriateness, attached
hereto as Exhibit "A ", meets the criteria for approval as a Special Certification of
Appropriateness under Chapter 171 of the City Code. The City's Historic Preservation Board
hereby approves the proposed demolition and reconstruction of the Sunny Isles Beach Pier with
no special conditions.
Resolution No. 2011 - Sunny Isles Beach Pier Page l of 2
Section 3. Effective Date. This Resolution will become effective upon adoption.
PASSED AND ADOPTED this -[J:� day of ,201 1.
Jo asters, hair
S y Isles Beach Historic Preservation Board
AT ST:
Jane A. Hines, CMC, City Clerk
APPROVED AS TO FORM
AND LEGAL SUFFICIENCY:
Hans Ottinot, City A rney
Moved by: SEE 11�2.� 1. +►�
Seconded by: W kfz('>"
Vote as Follows: `-] - O
Joe Masters, Chairperson
Aeo (Yes)
(No)
Cassey Gabor, Vice Chairperson
(Yes)
(No)
Janet R. Cini
(Yes)
(No)
Trina Duluc
V (Yes)
(No)
Shari Blank
1Z(Yes)
(No)
Mark Glicksman
_�/ (Yes)
(No)
Warren J. Stamm
✓ (Yes)
(No)
Resolution No. 2011 - Sunny Isles Beach Vier Page 2 of 2
e SUNNY ,s,F
° Historical Preservation Board
Richard C. Schulman, City Historian
City of Sunny Isles Beach
ofFSOa 18070 Collins Avenue, Fourth Floor
Sunny Isles Beach, Florida 33160
Telephone 305- 792 -1700
APPLICATION FOR A CERTIFICATION OF APPROPRIATENESS
I. PROPERTY INFORMATION:
Site Designation Name: Sunny Isles Beach Pier/Newport Fishing Pier (the "Pier ").
Property Address: 16701 Collins Avenue, Sunny Isles Beach, Florida 33160
LEGAL DESCRIPTION:
The Pier begins 76 ft. N of NE Corner of Lot 36, Bella Vista PB 8 -128 the E ALG N/L of S
10B 149.23 ft. to POB NELY 433.13 ft. E 328.63 ft. to East harbor line S 433.32 ft. to N/L of
S 1 O produces the W 3 51.0 8 ft. to POB.
II. THIS SECTION TO BE COMPLETED BY THE OFFICE
Date of Designation: The Pier was originally designated as a historic site by the Miami -
Dade County Historic Preservation Board on January 21, 1982,
Designation No. 8109.
Date of Re- designation: The Pier was recommended for re- designation as a historic site by
the Historic Preservation Board of the City of Sunny Isles Beach
on June 6, 2005 via Historic Preservation Board Resolution 2005-
3, Re- designation No. 4. On July 14, 2005, the City Commission
of the City of Sunny Isles Beach officially re- designated the Pier as
a historic site via Resolution No. 2005 -808.
III. APPLICANT INFORMATION:
Name(s) of Owner: City of Sunny Isles Beach
Name of Applicant: City of Sunny Isles Beach
Address of Applicant: 18070 Collins Avenue, Sunny Isles Beach, Florida 33160
Applicant telephone number: (305) 792 -1701
Page 1 of 7 EXHIBIT "A"
Please indicate below if applicant is requesting a Standard or Special Certificate of
Appropriateness. (Definitions are on page 5.)
STANDARD
SPECIAL XXXX
ALL APPLICATIONS SHALL INCLUDE ONE OR TWO 3" X 5" COLOR
PHOTOGRAPHS OF THE DESIGNATED PROPERTY AND PROJECT PLANS.
(A complete copy of Pier reconstruction plans and specifications are on file with the City
Clerk's Office.)
IV. THE PROPOSED PROJECT WILL INCLUDE: (Please check those that apply to your
project. See page 5 for definitions and requirements.)
❑ Maintenance or Repair
❑ Restoration
❑ Rehabilitation
❑
Excavation
®
Demolition
®
New Construction
❑
Relocation
V. DESCRIPTION OF THE PROPOSED PROJECT: (Please describe what
changes will be made to the following items and how they will be accomplished)
A. Building Features: New restaurant on top of the pier.
Structural System: CBS (concrete block structure)
Roofs and Roofing System: Yes.
Windows and Doors: Yes.
Page 2 of 7
Materials (masonry, wood, metal): Concrete deck on concrete piling for pier with composite
reinforced PVC railing.
Porches, Steps, and Stairways: Not applicable.
Painting and Finishes: Yes.
Additions: Not applicable.
Demolition: This project calls for the demolition of the Pier and its restaurant and its
replacement with a new Pier and restaurant within the same footprint of the
original Pier.
B. Environmental Features:
Landscaping: Not applicable.
Tree Removal: Not applicable.
Excavations (trenching /footers, swimming pool, etc.):
Concrete piles will be driven into the ground to minimize the impact of
construction in the beach area.
Fence Construction: There will be a construction fence located in the beach area during
construction.
Walls: Not applicable.
C. Overall Description of the Project (Please explain the chronology of the work
involved and describe all new construction excavation, demolition, and relocation
that will be required. Describe how the building or property will be used upon
completion. (Use the back of this sheet or another sheet if needed.):
The Pier, located at 16701 Collins Avenue, was originally built in 1936 and has long
been a major attraction for local residents and tourists. The Pier is the last remaining
public pier in Miami -Dade County. Millions of tourists have visited or fished from
Page 3 of 7
the Pier since it was built in 1936. The Pier was a much cherished memory in the
minds of many and photographs reveal the Pier was almost always crowded with
visitors. However, much of the original Pier structure was constructed of wood
which was no match for the devastation wrought over the past 75 years by sea, sand
and hurricanes. The Pier was badly damaged during Hurricane Wilma in 2005 and
has been since closed to the public due to unsafe conditions.
This project calls for the demolition of the Pier and its restaurant and its replacement
with a new Pier and restaurant within the same footprint of the original Pier. The new
Pier addresses Americans with Disabilities ( "ADA ") accessibility issues and provides
increased public amenities to accommodate local fishing enthusiasts and sightseers
from around the world. The Pier will include a restaurant and will be used as a
fishing pier and sightseeing attraction. The new Pier will consist of building
materials such as concrete, reinforced steel and reinforced PVC to ensure its
longevity. The completed project will re- establish the Pier as one of the City's major
landmarks_
Signature of the A
,-� L01
Signature of the Owner (if dim nt om abdive):
Date: -'! -' 2 (if.
Page 4 of 7
DEFINITIONS
Maintenance or Repair: The act or process of applying measures to sustain the existing form,
integrity, and material of a building or structure and the existing form or vegetative cover of a
site. It may include initial stabilization work, where necessary, as well as on -going maintenance
and repair. Samples of material may be requested.
Restoration: The process of accurately recovering the form and details of a property and
its setting as it appeared at a particular time by means of the removal of later work or by the
replacement of missing earlier work All applications for restoration shall include: elevations, site
and landscape plans (if necessary). A 300 -word statement with bibliography justifying the
work and any additional photographs or information to support the proposed work.
Rehabilitation: The process of returning a property to a state of utility through repair or
alteration which makes possible an efficient contemporary use while preserving those portions
or features of the property which are significant to its historical, architectural, and cultural
values. All applications for rehabilitation shall include: elevations, site and landscape plans (if
necessary), and other supplementary information that will support the proposed project.
Excavation: The process of performing an archaeological dig to recover artifacts, historical
material, or other archaeological features. It is recommended that the applicant include a 300 -
word statement describing the project, its methodology, and where the recovered material will
be disposed-
Demolition: The process of destroying or tearing down a building or structure or a part thereof
or the process of removing or destroying an archeological site or a part thereof. The
Applicant(s) shall include a report explaining why the proposed action should occur. If this
action is to occur for financial hardships all pertinent financial data should be included
pertaining to the cost (if preservation, demolition and new construction. Any other material to
the application is also encouraged as supplementary information.
New Construction: The process of constructing a building or structure that has never existed at
that location. Applications shall include: a site plan, elevations, floor plan, and landscape plan.
Relocation: The process of moving a building or structure from its current foundation to
another site. Applications shall include a report justifying the relocation and indicating that
efforts to preserve the building would not be feasible and justifying the proposed relocation site.
Special Certificate of Appropriateness — Those certificates involving the demolition, removal,
reconstruction, alteration or new construction of an individual site or in a district which requires
determination by the Historic Preservation Board before such certificate can be issued.
Standard Certificate of Appropriateness — Those certificates based on such guidelines and
standards, as may be officially adopted by the Historic Preservation Board, and for which
issuance has been authorized by such board upon findings by the Board that proposed actions are
in accord with such official guidelines and standards.
Page 5 of 7
REGULAR CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS:
❑ On -site Inspection
❑ Analysis Preparation
❑ Notification of Decision
❑ Additional Materials Requested
STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS:
Date
Date
Date
Date Received
Date of Expiration
Expiration of Grace Period
Approved ❑ Denied ❑ Approved, pending modifications ❑ Final Approval
Signature of Historic Preservation Board Chairperson
Page 6 of 7
Date
P
SPECIAL CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS:
® On -site Inspection
® Analysis Preparation
® Owner Notification Advertisement
9 Notification of Decision
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Date January 31, 2011
Date February 14, 2011
Date January 31, 2011
Date
Staff recommends approval of the project with no conditions.
Approved X Denied ❑ Approved, pending modifications ❑ Final Approval
Signa of the Historic Preservation Board Chairperson
Sign'f' s Approval of Special Certificates of Appropriateness
Page 7 of 7
2 ZS
Date
I
I
i
i
j4rff::,
I �
i
r
r
I
I
RED 1 1348 PC 24.5
i 11�
•.J 7 �IJ
II REA
REVISED SUNNY ISLES PIER DESIGNATION MAP:
Site Location - Legal Description:
Included with the title, but not a part of the,legal description, is that portion
of the Newport.Hote.l..- premises known as the fishing pier as Pthe same extends east-
ward and..-outward into the,.Atlantic Ocean within the following area: Beginning
at apoint on the north side of the Sunny Isles Ocean qeach Boulevard right -of -way,
wes.:ferly 78 feet from the established harbor line; thence:
easterly 1,000 feet outward into the Atlantic Oczean; thence 56 feet northerly;
thence 1,000 feet westerly; thence 50 feet soLhcrly to the point of beginning;
the `.intent of said parcel. being to enclose the structure known as the Sunny Isles
.Y.
Fishing Pier.
RFOORDED III OFFICIAL RECORDS 11001.
OF DUDE COUNTY. FLORID.
RECORD MIMI)
RICHARD P: BRINHE14
CLERK CIRCUIT COURT.
EC F 11348
•
245
R' '
r,; t
-tl T-lLvt)
RCA
I =too
AN
UJ) NOIIVA373
9
'7'0'd ,g uoyonJ; su. 0
m
„0 -191
m u� o�nruoququq
m
o In o M o In
M N N
o
'ON ;aayS aBS
l
4
_ Oh8
09'L£ +41 'DIS Bm7 yD ;o;y
III
I
a
�
=—
--
I 9'DN lua97J
I
Ci
a
a s
h
"a�r
bb')JaA
I
�•
�
� q
m q q° 2
O
m
C° Q o I LQ -,41
I
22
K
Cv
II II II II II
W
I
ti
-ON
L ;ueg
J
E
•`
•
I IL -__
__� ym
I I r - --
- -1 W �,
1
2 III
;
aZ
mO
•
°
II- - --
y
�
W
o
y4 N4
�h� me
__-
II
- -7
N_
_j
r
0
'a°
U
z.
II
��
O9'L4 +£1 .oIS
7j
I
-__
--_�"'�
- -'
970N ;uag
�.°'.m¢�1 m
mm I m
- -_
�
1
ZO
W
huf UJ
�y
]3
V7O
m
h
U d2•�
W
I° II
I
I Z
y4ti2�O
O(0
=o
m
to mmmr
I
I W
U
a
02
2
In m2mmm.a a
h
I
L-
O9'01 +£1 'DIS
CL m m X p m o p h
p d' a li
- _i____
� •ag
.9 'oN l UaI
--
--
2 y o
W oG 2 rn
`;h
U D C `K ul
m
c•',
ti 4WWW WSW O
In
o .0
I
I
w X11
m
'?.X L
2'.NM �h�p l� O
�
m
h4 WN
.c
i •k
.0000
W
O9'LL +Z1 'D)S
-_ -"
- -"
000'61 73
--t - --
�'
4'- N)uBg3
09'6L +L!'DIS IAd
II
0
0
_,
,I
°
„� I
1
fill
a
-4
O a
II
0
2
I
'o
—
�
000'61 '13
rn -W3 W
_
I
I
OS'ZY +ZI ;S'
09'Z9 +£I IAd
--
_--
- --
A
v 000'6173
0S'Zt +Z1'DIS IAd
I
I
•
•
II
02
- --
-�
h
m
h
C W 0
4 I
-
og.zo+ef -DIS
v 000'ti173
L9'£6 +6 'DIS IAd
_ LO-,O
m _ --
I
I
-I
h
Z
U
--
--
o
°i
ire
a
h
o W �`
II
e
•
a
�� ll c
OS'ZL +11 'D)S
'9
6wys�j u(bag
� ;
m,c
I
I
s •
� u
Q W� a p p
I� - - -I
-_ _-
oy�
II
8
I
r
00'09 +9I 'o ;S &W7 EINCH
0
i
0
7
09'Z9 +9!'o7S
- --
--
W y
I OO
R e
®
Ci
v
Q
R
,Co
O
v
4�
U
c
�os•zz +sr •oas
- --
--
Or 'ON We
.c
Of -ON JuDS
o9•Z9 +s1 •o;s
a
w
U 0
U N
0
0 b
N
l 0 0
as
d W Q
m y
a
N�,m2
O i 0 Cm
,
RWW�n
A 4 0 11 II II
c
0
0
a°
W` p
0
J Q
y a
3
2
m
9
0
0! O
W y
I OO
R e
m _
Q
U
4�
E6
09'90 +S1 -o ;S
t a
.c
Of -ON JuDS
0
of � ro
7
9
09•99 +67 -o7S
--
o, 6'ON We
°v
-• -
-_
PT -S 'ON 7aa4S eaS
OS'ZC +Yf 'o ;S 0417 YOMN
J 4
� � m
df
o (13) NOUVA373 n
IF
p :o
p `
a
O Cvi W � N W E
S
N N
U-4) NOI-LVA313
W y
o
R e
m _
4�
ti 2
W
t a
y°
I
- I
II
I
Q
III
I
WO
m
jo
Ln
-�n
$
12p2o I
m �
T
;3
ry
II
j Wyu
13
3
NO
'm
Om
w
F - --
= - -7
>-a
0
II
I
~
a
II
I
0
2
I
w
I
Via
III
--
- - -I
N
=-
_ _
- - -I
I
IF
O
1
O O
1 1
O
1
I _ J
' {Ja^
I I
y a ° III
- -_
---
_ - -I
- - -�
w I
I
IF
II
_
I
III
og
a
III
I
III
Z°
I
II
I
I
I
p
�2
III
I
U-4) NOI-LVA313
1
m
a
m
0
U
0
U W
b y
m
N O
l d
h b
m m�
4 04
O ° a
V m N
N 4�m
p c i O
d,v y23
bdW O�.0
y UDt xl
k k J m O
dWWO FIn
II II II II X II
J
,CO
Ul
w
0
3
U
m
O
a
1�
u
o o b
m
d U C.
C^-,h
OS'ZO +Lf'o7S
O N
z
aci
lit mm
+
O HIIn 4�
j°'
p L •"
o
O
Wow In
a
a`
Y
Z �
1
2 v
�h W
ate:
o o b
I
U
OS'ZO +Lf'o7S
O N
- --
aci
u
O HIIn 4�
z
a
® ® o
--
--a
o 0
Y
Z �
m
m z
a r
0
zi
]3
„v-,ty
Ln
a
,C
.y
W
0
m
o'
aI
4
o C
m j
o y
G C
No
O cyl
m
2
y
H
°z
2
U-P NOUVA373
7 i
ti
5
M
O e
W �
S
� a F
h i s
W
2 � i
Q
2
ate:
I
U
OS'ZO +Lf'o7S
----
- --
I
u
. ............. _----
a
O
i
o
Y
Z �
m
m z
a r
0
zi
]3
-
0 0
�
6l-8_'oN. ;aayS aeS.
LL _j
Om
1
0
o 0
00'08 +91 'o1S aW7 YD16W
o
I-
a
a
a
o
u
J
N
C
O
U
FY
.y
W
Ln
a
,C
.y
W
0
m
o'
aI
4
o C
m j
o y
G C
No
O cyl
m
2
y
H
°z
2
U-P NOUVA373
7 i
ti
5
M
O e
W �
S
� a F
h i s
W
2 � i
Q
2
b
ate:
I
U
i >•< °�
woW
I
fD �
N
a
JD
Ny
o
Y
Z �
�
zi
]3
-
NU
m
LL _j
Om
w
7
} a
o
I-
a
U
a
�g 3�Sq
I I
I
U �i `E
My
g
b
ate:
v
i >•< °�
I
c
I I
I
.sae
I II
I
III
i
I II
I
W
g
h I o -,sf .x
I II I
o I II j c
O J
W I^ Wy m
0
w
2 a
� y
k
W
y O y O y O y O y
N N '• ^' I i I
1 I
Ill NOIIIA113
Cl)
in
tn
m
u
u
d
L
d
C,
u
Qr
Oi
C
O
L
-P
4-
cf
N
in
U/
s
0
C)
0
/
N
7
I
NEWPORT PIER BUILT 1936
DADE COUNTY DESIGNATION JANUARY 219 1982